📋

Description

This error signifies a fundamental issue with the `GROUP BY` clause in a SQL query. It typically occurs when non-aggregated columns in the `SELECT` list are not present in the `GROUP BY` clause, or when aggregate functions are used incorrectly, violating SQL's grouping rules.

💬

Error Message

grouping error

🔍

Known Causes

3 known causes

⚠️

Non-Aggregated Columns

The `SELECT` list contains columns that are not part of an aggregate function and are also not included in the `GROUP BY` clause.

⚠️

Misplaced Aggregate Filters

Attempting to filter aggregated results using aggregate functions in the `WHERE` clause instead of the `HAVING` clause.

⚠️

Incorrect `GROUP BY` Syntax

Syntax errors within the `GROUP BY` clause itself, such as referencing a column alias not yet available or misspelling column names.

🛠️

Solutions

4 solutions available

1. Include All Non-Aggregated Columns in GROUP BY easy

Ensure all columns selected that are not aggregate functions are present in the GROUP BY clause.

1

Examine your `SELECT` statement. Identify all columns that are listed directly (not within an aggregate function like `COUNT()`, `SUM()`, `AVG()`, `MAX()`, `MIN()`).

SELECT column1, column2, aggregate_function(column3) FROM your_table GROUP BY ...;

2

For each of these non-aggregated columns, add them to your `GROUP BY` clause. The order in the `GROUP BY` clause generally doesn't matter for correctness but can affect performance.

SELECT column1, column2, aggregate_function(column3) FROM your_table GROUP BY column1, column2;

3

Re-run your query. The error should be resolved.

2. Use Aggregate Functions for All Non-Grouped Columns easy

If you intend to select columns that are not part of the grouping, wrap them in an aggregate function.

1

Identify the columns in your `SELECT` list that are not included in the `GROUP BY` clause.

SELECT column1, column2, aggregate_function(column3) FROM your_table GROUP BY column1;

2

Decide how you want to aggregate these non-grouped columns. Common choices include `MAX()` or `MIN()` if you expect only one distinct value per group, or `ARRAY_AGG()` to collect all values into an array.

SELECT column1, MAX(column2) AS max_column2, aggregate_function(column3) FROM your_table GROUP BY column1;

3

Modify your `SELECT` statement to apply the chosen aggregate function to these columns.

SELECT column1, MAX(column2) AS max_column2, aggregate_function(column3) FROM your_table GROUP BY column1;

4

Execute the modified query.

3. Remove Non-Aggregated Columns from SELECT easy

Simplify your query by removing columns from the SELECT list that are not aggregated and not in the GROUP BY clause.

1

Review your `SELECT` statement and `GROUP BY` clause. Note any columns in the `SELECT` list that are neither aggregated nor present in the `GROUP BY` clause.

SELECT column1, column2, aggregate_function(column3) FROM your_table GROUP BY column1;

2

If these columns are not essential for the output of this specific query, remove them from the `SELECT` list.

SELECT column1, aggregate_function(column3) FROM your_table GROUP BY column1;

3

Re-run the simplified query.

4. Utilize DISTINCT ON for Unique Rows Within Groups medium

When you need one representative row per group, `DISTINCT ON` is a more efficient PostgreSQL-specific solution than subqueries or complex `GROUP BY`.

1

Understand your goal: you want to select a single row for each distinct value in one or more columns, and you want to specify which row is chosen based on ordering.

2

Identify the column(s) you want to group by (these will be the arguments to `DISTINCT ON`).

SELECT DISTINCT ON (grouping_column1, grouping_column2) other_column1, other_column2 FROM your_table ORDER BY grouping_column1, grouping_column2, ordering_column DESC;

3

Identify the column(s) you want to use for ordering within each group. This `ORDER BY` clause is crucial for `DISTINCT ON` to determine which row is considered 'first'.

SELECT DISTINCT ON (grouping_column1, grouping_column2) other_column1, other_column2 FROM your_table ORDER BY grouping_column1, grouping_column2, ordering_column DESC;

4

Construct your query using `DISTINCT ON (column_list)`. Make sure the `ORDER BY` clause includes the `DISTINCT ON` columns first, followed by the columns that determine the specific row to pick.

SELECT DISTINCT ON (customer_id) customer_id, order_date, total_amount FROM orders ORDER BY customer_id, order_date DESC;

5

Execute the query. This will return one row per `customer_id`, specifically the row with the latest `order_date` for that customer.

🔗

Related Errors

5 related errors

PostgreSQL Error 42803: Grouping Clause Syntax Error